Clickbooth Invalidates Essociate Affiliate Pooling Patent Claims Again!

Written on
Mar 22, 2016 
Adotas  |

Clickbooth is pleased to announce that on March 11, 2016, during the appeal of the Essociate, Inc. v., LLC suit, the Federal Circuit Panel unanimously affirmed the prior decision in favor of Clickbooth which effectively invalidated Essociate’s affiliate pooling patent.

Essociate has used its patent to sue more than 20 companies in the affiliate industry. While many other companies find it easier to simply settle the case, Clickbooth chose to take a stand for the industry and invest the resources to defeat Essociate. Last February, Clickbooth defeated Essociate in the first round of the patent battle.

Essociate filed an appeal and again, Clickbooth stepped up to the challenge. During the appeal oral arguments, Federal Circuit and Lead Judge Hughes said he was not convinced that Essociate had demonstrated patentability of its improvements on the Web merchant referral system, which is itself likely unpatentable. This week the appellate court affirmed U.S. District Judge James V. Selna’s 2015 ruling that Essociate’s claims were without merit.

Clickbooth counsel Richard Newman said that the company was pleased with the ruling, obviously a great result for Clickbooth but also for all the other participants in the industry, saying, “This ruling is a victory for Internet marketing companies who should not have to face patents directed to fundamental economic practices”.

Clickbooth CEO, Erin Cigich (pictured top left), commented, “Clickbooth’s triumph over this appeal proves that the interests of the affiliate marketing industry are worth fighting for and protecting, something we will continue to do to help our industry grow”.

About Clickbooth

Clickbooth, The Performance Exchange, is a technology company that takes a programmatic approach to traditional performance marketing. The company’s proprietary and patent pending performance exchange provides advertisers looking for new customer acquisitions access to the largest distribution network of online marketing experts, specializing in display, social, native, search and contextual traffic. Affiliates using the platform see 30% higher EPCs and let the platform handle optimization, cap management and offer testing for them, allowing them to aggressively scale their businesses.

Founded in 2002, Clickbooth’s mission is to empower small businesses, entrepreneurs and Fortune 500 companies alike, allowing all to compete on a level playing field for media – based on performance. In 2015, Clickbooth pioneered the world’s first marketplace to automate performance advertising and support innovation leading to superior results for advertisers, affiliates and consumers.


ADOTAS, founded in 2003, is a premier news publication focused on the Internet advertising and media industry. ADOTAS features a twice-daily email newsletter and web site and is proud to reach well over 100,000 advertising professionals monthly.

ADOTAS was acquired by New York Publishing Group Inc. in May 2007. Our emphasis is on providing the best news and information on media buying, planning, selling, technology and activities of the digital media business to the interactive advertising community. We are proud to have over 100 contributing writers, including the foremost experts in the field.

ADOTAS has built on a tradition of excellence to become the most trusted source of information among leaders in the online marketplace. Professionals read, comment and learn from our publication each day.

Reader Comments.

No comments yet

Leave a Comment

Add a comment

Tags: , and
Article Sponsor

More News