Thoughts on the Affiliate Brain Drain
DM CONFIDENTIAL - This year has not been a particularly easy one for certain segments of the performance marketing space. It is the banking crisis plus the auto crisis all rolled into one — the storied companies and iconic brands facing iconic struggles, with debt crushing them and forcing once-unthinkable situations. Unfortunately, for the performance marketing space, no government bailouts exist to lend them the money and time they need to stay afloat. And, while not as massive in scale, the almost domino-like failure of the networks has similarly devastating consequences for the downstream publishers who rely on them for their own livelihood.
Even as recently as a year ago, the failure of a company like Epic Advertising would have seemed impossible. That Epic and many of its peers had made aggressive and ultimately faulty bets was known, but perhaps the financial crisis had us thinking failure just couldn’t happen, which in Epic’s network business took place eight days ago.
As is the case when big companies fail, controversy around both decisions past and present exist. That has happened here. There were early signs that something was amiss given that certain senior management members’ emails started to come from new domain that no one else had heard of. Going to the new domain’s site only caused more confusion, as there was an internal division doing the same thing. (Note AdExchanger’s great post on the subject, What Happened Epic Media Group? See Kinetic Social.)
There is enough classic corporate “survival/thrival” to only want to focus on the nuances of what happened, and we are not saying that this isn’t incredibly relevant or important, especially for those who are waiting on payment from what they thought was the parent company. For us, though, a more addressable topic is how we got to where we are. What has fundamentally changed in the affiliate/performance marketing space? Put simply, finding offers and running them on traffic platforms as is — i.e., not playing in the gray, from copy to IP blocking to pages — is a surefire way to lose money and gain lots of frustration.
Here are some of the reason that we typically use to describe this current state of performance marketing:
Lack of offer diversity: OfferVault has thousands of offers, but see above as to what that really means. In this space, the one thing that has sustained so many is subscription-based offers, which tie into to the second type — promo offers. The latter work because they are truly content-agnostic, and many have had to fish in even muddier streams, where only those can run.
Traffic source saturation: There aren’t any new ones at scale that others don’t know about. The newest, Twitter, has gone top-down in its approach — brands first before opening up to the masses. That leaves only the gray by spamming content.
Unsubstantiated technology: It is a commodity business that lends money — that has been the boom and bust. Sometimes companies can differentiate through offers, but that has been an ever-difficult proposition.
Technology is differentiator: Looking at those who seem to be succeeding, it is the platform companies — those who initially helped spawn the seemingly endless number of networks. They still have a healthy business there, but enabling advertisers has been the more recent focus. That has lead to…
Disintermediation: – Advertisers becoming networks. A great advertiser will attract traffic sources. They don’t have to rely on they networks as gate keepers.
We could stop there. It should be sufficient to help explain why companies went down the path they did, that of relying on unsustainable offers and loading up on debt. But, is that really the problem? We initially thought so, but then, a conversation with a recent ex-marketer changed everything.
What’s really changed are the people. There are fewer of them.
In years past, the growth hacker, as Andrew Chen is popularizing, did marketing. He/she did arb. He didn’t go to work at a big company, and for the most part he didn’t go work at Google. But Facebook, iOS and the new web has changed that. He doesn’t do marketing. The old marketer builds things today. Just check out this list, also by Andrew. A few of these people used to hover in the performance marketing space. The “newer” ones, also on the list, would have no idea about our space. That is the problem. Why try and make even seven figures a year when you can get plugged into one of the biggest ecosystems around and take a spin for tens if not hundreds of millions along with positive notoriety?
The new marketer takes a little bit of money from the likes of Y-Combinator, Tech Stars, and 500 Startups. They get a three-month intensive with business advice, spending time with peers, and most importantly in their minds a path for real profits — being acquired. That is the new self-funded money — exchanging some of their brain for early equity. And, while this model exists — while big-but-nimble companies like Facebook and Zynga can’t hire enough, needing to acquire instead — that’s where the talent will continue to go.
Leave a Comment
- Big-Budget TV Ads Alone Aren’t Enough: Use Programmatic to Tell Your Brand Story
- 5 Keys to Capitalizing on the Mobile Gaming Phenomenon
- The Programmatic Future: Automation Poised to Dominate Video Ad Buying
- You Have My Data, Now Stop Retargeting Me!
- The Top 5 New Video Ads: Snickers, Pepsi, HUVr, Hugo Boss
- MediaBrix Launches In-Game Ad SDK for Intel’s Latest Platform March 12th 2014 NEW YORK, March 12, 2014 (ADOTAS) — MediaBrix, the leading [...] more »
- Fiverr® Updates iPhone App: Puts Over 3 Million Gigs® in the Palm of Your Hand March 12th 2014 NEW YORK, March 12, 2014 — Fiverr®, the world’s largest [...] more »
- BroadbandTV CEO is Named Young Global Leader by the World Economic Forum March 11th 2014 VANCOUVER, March 11, 2014 (ADOTAS) – Shahrzad Rafati, founder and CEO [...] more »
- Intent Media Hires Noted Travel Industry Exec Noreen Henry as VP of Business Development March 11th 2014 NEW YORK, March 11, 2014 (ADOTAS) — Intent Media, an [...] more »
- Ampush Appoints Rick Cotton as Chief Revenue Officer March 11th 2014 SAN FRANCISCO, March 11, 2014 (ADOTAS) – Ampush, a leading [...] more »
- Facebook Exchange Partner Perfect Audience Taps into Google Merchant Accounts for Retargeting March 11th 2014 ADOTAS – You may already know that Facebook Exchange (FBX) [...] more »
- Covario Names Jeff MacGurn Senior Vice President March 11th 2014 SAN DIEGO, March 11, 2014 (ADOTAS) -– Covario, a leading independent [...] more »
- Big-Budget TV Ads Alone Aren’t Enough: Use Programmatic to Tell Your Brand Story March 12th 2014
- 5 Keys to Capitalizing on the Mobile Gaming Phenomenon March 11th 2014
- The Programmatic Future: Automation Poised to Dominate Video Ad Buying March 10th 2014
- You Have My Data, Now Stop Retargeting Me! March 7th 2014
- The Top 5 New Video Ads: Snickers, Pepsi, HUVr, Hugo Boss March 7th 2014
- Marketing Operations Manager - Healthcare
- Director Digital Engagements
- Website Designer
- Online Account Manager
- Online Media Buyer
- Adknowledge Acquires Video Syndicator Giant Media - Responsivemts | Responsivemts: [...] Fans Among Farmers, Filmmakers#Selfie Music Video Dominates With Help From Social Media InfluencersAdknowledge Acquires
- Today’s Burning Question: Instagram’s $100 Million Ad Deal with Omnicom - Responsivemts | Responsivemts: [...] Tech Companies Must Improve EncryptionThe (Important) SXSW Panels You Missed, Explained by CartoonsToday’s Burning
- Bitly Adds New Leadership, Partners with Moz for Inbound Link Marketing Intelligence - Responsivemts | Responsivemts: [...] Live Video: Edward Snowden at SXSWSheryl Sandberg Teams Up With Beyonce to Ban
- Finding Your Brand Advocates, Are You Ready for Super Bowl Sunday? - Inside CXM: [...] Theresa Trevor, Adotas, offers 5 simple rules to motivate brand advocates: [...]