Smart Investors Systematically Undervalue SEO
They’re both wrong: public perception of SEO is, by nature, a few years behind the industry most of the time. Why?
1. People are usually aware of SEO when it’s done badly: most people think of news as “news” and not a smart SEO play; most people think of keyword-stuffed articles as SEO, not as an obsolete SEO strategy.
2. The people who try to rank for SEO-related terms are usually selling high-margin, low price-point products, which tend to be scalable and commoditized.
So it’s understandable that the average person who thinks about SEO thinks of it as a set of strategies for making a site search engines will like, at the expense of making a site humans would like instead. But that’s not an accurate description. Due to some forces that are intrinsic to the practice of SEO, and some that have emerged from the way the industry is structured, SEO isn’t just about gaming: it’s word of mouth marketing, rethought as a science.
At SEO conferences (like this one, where DDD will be part of a panel), there are still a few talks about the back-end technical issues. But that’s not what gets people excited. Hot topics now are:
- How to write content that convinces people to share it.
- How social sharing signals impact search.
- How search engines are adapting to different kinds of queries—the default schema for product search is completely different from the default for people search, discussion search, or local search.
Other kinds of marketing consider these factors, but SEO focuses on them more than pretty much anyone else. People practicing explicit “word of mouth” marketing or social media marketing are aware of these factors, but they don’t have the numbers to back them up.
This wasn’t part of some long-term plan; SEO used to be almost entirely a matter of gaming search engines, not catering to users. A few forces have caused this change:
1. Search plus social monetizes better than social alone: so far, Bing and Google have done very well with socially-enhanced ads—per pageview, they’ve probably benefited far more than any of the social media sites whose data they use. Meanwhile, social media sites haven’t managed to turn search into a major income stream.
2. Search is an oligopoly at the high end and anarchy at the low end. There are a couple big search companies with basically limitless appetite for experimentation. And then there are the independent search engines, the vertical-specific search engines, etc.
The larger search engines innovate glacially but precisely—every change they make has been bucket-tested against every possible alternative. The smaller search engines change more experimentally.
Basically, it’s an environment where every search engine is evolving towards better reflecting user psychology. The optimal SEO strategy is to optimize for the search engine of the future.
3. SEO as a career only makes sense if it’s not commoditized. Very few people can make a living as SEO copywriters; the market wage is enough to pay costs of living overseas, but not in the U.S. So American SEOs are gradually transitioning into SEO-sensitive web development or SEO-sensitive general online marketing. Since search engines are relentlessly expanding their use of nontraditional signals, every online marketing field is gradually bleeding into search.
This is visible if you’re in the SEO industry, but it’s invisible to almost everyone else. Facebook marketers didn’t see the Facebook/Bing deal as paradigm-shattering; SEOs didn’t, either, because they saw that general trend coming.
In lots of fields, an article that starts with “People are wrong about X…” has to end with “…and here’s what to do about it!” But in a comparatively efficient market, that’s pretty much pointless: what you do about other people’s mistakes is that you profit from not making them.
Did Gavin Dunaway write this or did Byrne Hobart?
- Pingback from Smart Investors Systematically Undervalue SEO – ADOTAS | News About Google | Latest Changes and happening in Google
- Pingback from SEO undervalued ? | Domain Industry News
Byrne wrote this — my sloppiness in editing is at fault for the mix-up. I could only dream of being as insightful as Byrne.
great post, I am wondering what your thoughts are on the impact of Google+ on SEO and what you think Google has in store for the use of social signals and SEO rankings
Leave a Comment
Adknowledge Announces Launch of ‘AdStation International’KANSAS CITY, Mo., November 25, 2013 (ADOTAS) – Adknowledge is pleased to announce the launch of AdStation International, a global [...] more...
- UPDATED: Twitter Officially Launches Tailored Audiences Program December 6th 2013 ADOTAS – Twitter brought its tailored audiences ad program out [...] more »
- veeseo Launches Speech-to-Text Content Recognition Engine for Video Advertising December 6th 2013 ADOTAS — Video marketing company veeseo announced this week a [...] more »
- Today’s Burning Question: Massive Hack Attack Reaction December 5th 2013 ADOTAS – Today we’re featuring reactions from industry leaders to yesterday’s [...] more »
- Dell Software Exec: Strong Password Would Not Have Stopped Latest Hack December 5th 2013 ADOTAS — In response to Today’s Burning Question about reports [...] more »
- If You Waited for Black Friday/Cyber Monday, You Were Probably Too Late December 5th 2013 ADOTAS – While holiday shoppers have been conditioned to believe [...] more »
- Digital First Ventures, RealMatch Partner to Power JobsInTheUS.com December 5th 2013 NEW YORK, December 5, 2013 (ADOTAS) – Digital First Ventures, [...] more »
- Celtra Hires Ex-Adobe Exec Taplin as EVP of Global Sales December 5th 2013 CAMBRIDGE, Mass. – December 5, 2013 – Celtra Inc., the industry leader [...] more »
- Making Holiday Marketing Magic in 2013 December 6th 2013
- 5 New Video Ads You Should Watch Right Now December 6th 2013
- How Interactive Video is Helping Brands Engage with Their Customers December 5th 2013
- Is Putting Digital First Still Paramount for Advertisers? December 5th 2013
- Revenge of the Data Nerds: Who Will Be the Next Heartthrob of the B2B Data Market? December 4th 2013
- Manager Planner - Digital Vendor Marketing
- Brand Manager
- Publisher Services Manager
- Social Media Manager (Part-Time)
- Social Media Manager
- Text Marketing News December 6, 2013 | Text Marketing Companies: [...] veeseo Launches Speech-to-Text Content Recognition Engine for Video … – ADOTAS [...]
- Dell Software Exec: Strong Password Would Not Have Stopped Latest Hack: [...] — In response to Today’s Burning Question about reports of the latest major cyberattack,
- Zimmerman Advertising Has What White Castle Craves – ADOTAS | Zimmerman News: [...] more here: Google Zimmerman News In [...]
- Online Video Quality Matters More Than You Think | Video Industry | OneScreen: [...] so. In fact, branded videos are getting shared 50 times more in 2013 than