Books Say Google Is Scary AND Has Lost Its Mojo
First up is the “perhaps you’re not paranoid enough” entry, “The Googlization of Everything (And Why We Should Worry)” by media critic and professor Siva Vaidhyanathan. Google has turned into something out of the “Pit of Ultimate Darkness” — Evil, EVIL!!! Well, in the help-an-old-lady-with-her-groceries kind of way.
Actually, Vaidhyanathan is more concerned about “googlization” than Google (though he’s worried about Big G as well). Internet users are over-relying on ad-supported search engines that deliver results colored by advertisers, particularly local ones. Since Google equals search in so many Internet users minds (as well as their browser default settings), the company gets the most attention.
“Google, the most flexible yet powerful information filter we use regularly, could come to exercise inordinate influence over our decisions and values,” Vaidhyanathan explains. He argues Google is more about shopping than learning as results are filtered by what would encourage consumers to head to a local store.
While Google certainly provides a valuable service, Vaidhyanathan claims the company is overreaching, particularly in its goals to foster a digital library. He proposes something akin to a “Human Knowledge Project” headed up by state institutions.
But how users take advantage of Google Search is changing. As TechCrunch’s Mike Arrington argued a while back, searches increasingly already know what they are looking for and merely use Google as an ad-supported tour guide. How many people use Google searches to find Wikipedia pages? IMDB movie pages?
I’d argue that searchers understand Google is trying to influence their purchasing decisions — call it a tradeoff for the use of its Internet scouring engine. This also ties into the rise of social search — consciously or subconsciously, searchers are annoyed by this manipulation and are turning to signals from contacts and acquaintances to lead them to more valuable resources. Even Google recognizes this trend — perhaps you’ve heard of +1, its version of the Facebook Like?
So I don’t think Vaidhyanathan is giving Internet users enough credit — we’re smarter than we look.
On the other side, “In the Plex: How Google Thinks Works and Shapes Our Lives“ by tech journeyman Steven Levy, actually got modest approval from Matt Cutts, head of Google’s anti-spam,
An “inside-out” look at Google then and now, the most interesting part seems to be the giant’s numerous stumbles in the last few years — China, Wave and, who could forget, Buzz. (Certainly the Federal Trade Commission won’t be forgetting for the next 20 years.)
The Buzz stories are telling, and don’t set a good precedent for Google’s future social endeavors – especially since the engineers are running all the shops now and reporting directly to re-crowned CEO Larry Page.
The original code name for Buzz was “Taco Town,” based on a “Saturday Night Live” skit. According to Levy, the name ”reflected Googlers’ judgment of the Internet’s current social strategy: big messy layers of greasy, unwholesome stuff whose caloric volume tried to compensate,”
Now actually watch the skit (it’s short). The moral I see is: when you mash a bunch of stuff people are kinda into together in a haphazard fashion (I love the slopping of the chili in the tote bag at the very end), the end product is disturbing, messy and likely to get laughed at. Add a bunch of privacy lawsuits to the mix and it sounds like… Google Buzz.
At the center of that mess, there’s a perfectly good taco — Gmail — a straightforward dish that doesn’t need any more embellishment than a little salsa (priority inbox?).
Levy corroborates that nobody at Google was considering privacy issues as Buzz came to market. Interestingly, one Googler says, ”We should have known people were gunning for us,”
Even Google admits Buzz will forever be a scar on its social efforts, but it’s not clear if the company has learned anything from the debacle.
No comments yet
Leave a Comment
Take the Display Advertising Survey for the Chance to Win a Jawbone Jambox!ADOTAS – Industry discussions about cookies, privacy and the impact on display advertising have been frequent — and, in some [...] more...
- Watch it Live: Xbox Reveal, 5/21 at Noon EDT/10 a.m. PDT May 20th 2013 ADOTAS (via CNET) – Check out CNET’s live coverage of [...] more »
- Today’s Burning Question: Implications of Yahoo’s Tumblr Acquisition? May 20th 2013 ADOTAS – Today we’ve solicited comments from industry leaders in [...] more »
- AFAIK: Poptent, Clear Channel Outdoor, Infusionsoft, Silverpop May 20th 2013 ADOTAS — Here’s what jumped out of my Inbox and [...] more »
- Live Twitter feed from Internet Week New York May 20th 2013 ADOTAS – This year’s Internet Week New York (#IWNY) will [...] more »
- Preview: What’s Happening at Internet Week New York 2013 May 20th 2013 ADOTAS — Digital advertising and technology collide this week as [...] more »
- Report: David Karp sells Tumblr to Yahoo! for $1.1 Billion May 20th 2013 ADOTAS (via New York’s Daily News) — Who wants to [...] more »
- It’s Not Digital – It’s Mobile May 17th 2013 ADOTAS — One of the biggest mistakes advertisers can [...] more »
- Preview: What’s Happening at Internet Week New York 2013 May 20th 2013
- Video from the Westchester Digital Summit May 17th 2013
- Automating Core Processes Can Reduce ‘Little Big Problems’ That Ruin Customer Relationships May 17th 2013
- Unleash the Power of Mobile: 6 Steps to Lead Generation the ‘Iron Man’ Way May 16th 2013
- Who’s Sharing My Brand Images? Why Text-Based Social Media Monitoring Falls Short May 16th 2013
- Print and Web Manager
- SEO Marketing PPC Specialist
- Marketing Summer Internship at Clean-Tech Educatio
- Service Line Manager - Digital Media
- SEO / SEM Specialist
- Pinterest Roundup — May 2013 | Technology for Publishing LLC: [...] Early Pinterest Analytics Show Brand Potential [...]
- YouTube Turns Eight As Platform Surpasses More Than 100 Hours Of Video … | HOW CAN I GET MONEY: [...] in the look, feel and behavior of Google Objects. The integration is easy, and
- MobiKeith: Well done. Gr8 read. Concepts can b used in general sales/marketing environment. Tx.
- Client News Weekly Wrap Up: [...] PunchTab founder and CEO Ramjet Kumaran, lists four best practices for using incentives to attract and