The ethical quandaries of virtual goods
ADOTAS – It was just another Virtual Goods Summit in San Francisco on Friday until TechCrunch’s Michael Arrington came up to the mic during an afternoon panel and questioned the ethics of bartering lead-generation data for virtual goods.
Offerpal CEO Anu Shukla responded by calling Arrington’s insights three types of excrement to a packed crowd’s approval.
On social media and gaming sites users can either buy virtual goods — to send as presents or enhance gameplay — with money or “barter” for them by taking surveys that provide lead-gen data. Arrington’s argument surrounded what he called a “downward spiral into hell” — in a blog post, he railed:
“Users are tricked into these lead gen scams. The games get paid, and they plow that money back into Facebook and MySpace in advertising, getting more users. Who are then monetized via lead gen scams. That money is then plowed back into Facebook and MySpace in advertising to get more users….”
His ire was inflated by the notion that many of these offers are aimed at minors who likely have no clue what they’re signing up for. He singled out Zynga, a highly successful social gaming company that receives a third of its revenue from companies providing commercial offers. In addition, he accused Facebook of facilitating the scamming of its users and capturing a monetary benefit.
Shukla countered that Facebook is not making lots of money from companies such as Zygna and Offerpal and that the company has in fact come down very hard with its advertising policy in the last several months, weeding out duplicitous advertising. She called the standards more stringent than the Federal Trade Commission’s.
Expanding on Shukla’s response, an Offerpal blog claimed that terms for completing any of its offers are clearly spelled out in its l-frame and on the advertiser’s landing page. Offerpal’s policies regarding misleading copy are similar to Facebook’s, and the company said it deletes unclear offers and bans the advertisers.
Arrington’s post has received many comments including anecdotes about unethical encounters; HotOrNot founder James Hong recounted his company’s experience with such offers, concluding: “the offers that monetize the best are the ones that scam/trick users.”
Virtual goods have become a $1 billion industry in the U.S. and a $7 billion industry in Asia; Facebook’s repeated updates of its advertising and privacy policies show it is definitely concerned about spurious tactics taking advantage of users. At the same time, game developers should be able to monetize their offerings.
Surely these tense 10 minutes are just the sparks of a fiery debate set to ignite the social mediascape. The video is well worth watching, but be warned that there is some explicit language.
Reader Comments.
No comments yet
Leave a Comment
Article Sponsor
More News
-
Loading ...
Latest News
- Funding in Brief: $10M for Spongecell, $8M for Prolexic February 9th 2012 ADOTAS – Rich media ad company Spongecell has raised $10 million [...] more »
- Google AdMob Axes Minimum Bids, Targeting Fees February 9th 2012 ADOTAS - As of Feb. 15, Google will change its [...] more »
- Infographic: HootSuite Analyses Social Media Impact of Super Bowl Ads February 7th 2012 ADOTAS - So, it’s the Tuesday after the Super Bowl, [...] more »
- Facebook to Serve Mobile Ads in Coming Weeks February 6th 2012 ADOTAS – According to a Financial Times report, Facebook will [...] more »
- Survey: 39 Percent of Mobile Users Responded to Super Bowl Ads Via Mobile February 6th 2012 ADOTAS - During the Super Bowl yesterday, mobile ad network [...] more »
- Sponsormob Leads the Way Into RTB for Mobile February 3rd 2012 ADOTAS – For more than half a decade, Berlin-based tech [...] more »
- Weird Study: Mobile Purchasing While in the Bathroom on the Rise February 3rd 2012 DM CONFIDENTIAL - According to 11mark, three-quarters of Americans with mobile [...] more »
Features
- Attribution Online: Introducers and Influencers and Closers… Oh My! February 9th 2012
- With gTLDs, Global Branding Starts with a Name February 9th 2012
- Rethinking the Online Advertising Ecosystem, Part One: Independent Publishers February 8th 2012
- Case Study: Social Ad Effectiveness February 8th 2012
- Video: “Build an SEO Foundation” Excerpt February 8th 2012
Spotlight
Sponsormob Leads the Way Into RTB for MobileADOTAS – For more than half a decade, Berlin-based tech firm Sponsormob has remained relevant in an industry characterized by [...] more...
Reader Favorites
Classifieds
- PS Technical Writer - SEO Data Analyst
- Interactive Project Manager
- Media Buyer
- PHP Software Engineer (Facebook Platform/Social AP
- SEO/Marketing Internship at Green Education Startu
Recent Comments
- News about Google Adwords issue #412: [...] ads for AdWords to adCenter and align with industry standards, adCenter has chang
- VB: What exactly makes an ad "high quality"?
- Survey: 39 Percent of Mobile Users Responded to Super Bowl Ads Via Mobile - ADOTAS | Mobile2 | Scoop.it: [...] background-position: 50% 0px; background-color:#222222; background-repeat : no-repeat; }
- Mobile Marketing News: [...] Survey: 39 Percent of Mobile Users Responded to Super Bowl Ads Via Mobile Meanwhile,
