Whining about cookies overstates problem
Gathering data to better target ads to users has breathed new life into the online ad industry, and the fear is that meddlesome regulations out of Washington will kill innovation and destroy a growing value proposition.
I don’t agree with that perspective and here are five reasons why:
1. The industry could use some oversight.
There are plenty of ways to use technology and non-PII data to safely target ads. At Bizo, for example, we use what we call “bizographic” data, information gathered by business sites that includes details such as job title and industry without any personal information. The use of this data allows for great B2B ad targeting and a better experience for both the business user and the publisher — all in a totally transparent environment.
2. Publishers need ads.
As worried as the ad industry is over the prospect of new laws cutting off revenue streams, publishers are equally uneasy about the possibility of losing a big source of income.
If publishers are going to lose much of the value they gain by providing free content in exchange for serving ads, they will go to a “gated” model just like with paid content. With even draconian opt-in regulations, users will simply be required to click a terms of service (”I opt-in to targeting”) before accessing the site’s content. If the user doesn’t want to opt in, then many publishers will send them to a payment form to access the content for a fee. The vast majority of users will simply accept the terms, and opt-in to targeted advertising in exchange for free content.
4. Consumers need ads — and targeted ads are better.
See above. We’re all addicted to free online content, (often to the chagrin of publishers), and without advertising, it can’t exist.
If targeting is hamstrung, the advertiser has to resort to “annoying” tactics like pop-ups and takeovers to raise attention levels. Have you noticed how ads get louder when you watch TV?
However, targeted ads work while creating a much better user experience: They are less annoying and more likely to be useful. If there is a clear user understanding that consumers are receiving free content in exchange for safely targeted ads, most consumers will agree to that tradeoff.
4. Opt-in can actually provide a better environment for relevant targeting.
Let’s use Google as an example. I understand that when I type my key words in the search bar, Google will serve me ads targeted to my search. In exchange, I get the search for free. The value equation is very clear.
Following this line of reasoning a step further, if all publishers begin to require an “opt-in” to view free content, cookies will be placed on the user’s browser indicating that they have accepted the terms on site xyz.com and can go ahead to the content. This will require a browser to accept these cookies. Then, if a user ever deletes their cookies, they will have to opt-in to all of those sites all over again. Thus, this requirement may actually lead to a better environment for legitimate cookie targeting, where cookies aren’t deleted nearly as frequently and the user trade-off is clear.
That clarity is something I think can’t be overstated. Success in this industry needs to be predicated on full transparency. If you have that, the notion of opting in or opting out isn’t even necessary — it’s all clear user tradeoffs. But if it takes an act of congress to bring this clarity to the market so be it.
5. Remember CAN-SPAM?
Check your spam filter. Did that piece of legislation, signed into law by President Bush in 2003, really end email marketing? This legislation won’t end online targeting either. But like CAN-SPAM, it may help to create more legitimacy and transparency.
Good piece, Russell. I think there is plenty more room for transparency and openness in the marketplace. Obviously there will be reluctance among those with highly vested interests to change what they are doing, but some change won’t hurt.
Leave a Comment
Adknowledge Announces Launch of ‘AdStation International’KANSAS CITY, Mo., November 25, 2013 (ADOTAS) – Adknowledge is pleased to announce the launch of AdStation International, a global [...] more...
- UPDATED: Twitter Officially Launches Tailored Audiences Program December 6th 2013 ADOTAS – Twitter brought its tailored audiences ad program out [...] more »
- veeseo Launches Speech-to-Text Content Recognition Engine for Video Advertising December 6th 2013 ADOTAS — Video marketing company veeseo announced this week a [...] more »
- Today’s Burning Question: Massive Hack Attack Reaction December 5th 2013 ADOTAS – Today we’re featuring reactions from industry leaders to yesterday’s [...] more »
- Dell Software Exec: Strong Password Would Not Have Stopped Latest Hack December 5th 2013 ADOTAS — In response to Today’s Burning Question about reports [...] more »
- If You Waited for Black Friday/Cyber Monday, You Were Probably Too Late December 5th 2013 ADOTAS – While holiday shoppers have been conditioned to believe [...] more »
- Digital First Ventures, RealMatch Partner to Power JobsInTheUS.com December 5th 2013 NEW YORK, December 5, 2013 (ADOTAS) – Digital First Ventures, [...] more »
- Celtra Hires Ex-Adobe Exec Taplin as EVP of Global Sales December 5th 2013 CAMBRIDGE, Mass. – December 5, 2013 – Celtra Inc., the industry leader [...] more »
- Making Holiday Marketing Magic in 2013 December 6th 2013
- 5 New Video Ads You Should Watch Right Now December 6th 2013
- How Interactive Video is Helping Brands Engage with Their Customers December 5th 2013
- Is Putting Digital First Still Paramount for Advertisers? December 5th 2013
- Revenge of the Data Nerds: Who Will Be the Next Heartthrob of the B2B Data Market? December 4th 2013
- Manager Planner - Digital Vendor Marketing
- Brand Manager
- Publisher Services Manager
- Social Media Manager (Part-Time)
- Social Media Manager
- Text Marketing News December 6, 2013 | Text Marketing Companies: [...] veeseo Launches Speech-to-Text Content Recognition Engine for Video … – ADOTAS [...]
- Dell Software Exec: Strong Password Would Not Have Stopped Latest Hack: [...] — In response to Today’s Burning Question about reports of the latest major cyberattack,
- Zimmerman Advertising Has What White Castle Craves – ADOTAS | Zimmerman News: [...] more here: Google Zimmerman News In [...]
- Online Video Quality Matters More Than You Think | Video Industry | OneScreen: [...] so. In fact, branded videos are getting shared 50 times more in 2013 than