Can great DHTML ads create false click-throughs?
Here’s an example of a great branding advertisement for GMC that is highly effective in branding and bringing a message. This is how DHTML/Rich Media advertising is meant to be done: integrate the advertisement into the content, draw attention to the message and the brand while getting the consumer involved. It’s almost a perfect advertisement for a brand that desperately needs more attention.
However, there is a slight problem. The advertisement moves left to right across the screen, but even when the “writing” is not over actual news content, any click-through in the general area will click-through to the landing page instead of the content on AOL.com. Users don’t mind these advertisements, but when they are attempting to get content, they do not want to accidentally click on them.
Additionally, if you accidentally click on the advertisement and then browser-back to AOL in an attempt to click through again to the content—in this occasion, the article about my senator, Hillary—you will again click-through to the landing page of the advertisement. One has to wait approximately 10 seconds to allow the advertisement to finish running (there is an X to exit) in order to click on the content, even when it seems that the advertisement has moved away from the content.
I need to be clear here: this is one of my favorite car ads I’ve seen so far in the last few weeks, and I actually went to the site to learn about the Yukon, a SUV I’ve looked at in the past. That being said, the creative community needs to address several issues regarding these types of advertisements:
1) Do they generate “false” click-throughs and thus create possible negative branding?
2) Is there a way to make sure that users do not accidentally click on the ad while trying to get to content? Can we prevent the entire area from being clickable, especially in examples like this when the advertisement is showing the actual content below it?
3) How do we make sure as a community that users do not decide that these are intrusive and start creating blocking options for them.
I’d love your feedback on this question.
(NB: After this was published, AOL actually changed the advertisement in response — and it is no longer a problem. When the writing is no longer over content,itwill click-through only to content. Kudos to AOL’steam to a fast response)
Reader Comments.
The click through should be limited to the 300×100 ad. The floating component should only serve to get your attention.
I saw a flash ad from a site last week that slightly moved the close “X” button when you moused-over, just before you clicked it so that you clicked on the ad instead. Devious.
Heck yeah, they are trying to generate false clicks. Why the heck would they have so much transparency? Back in the day, they’d do that when someone would pay for a CPM ad to try and increase their click-through rate. On a CPC, no one should allow a campaign with any technology that serves to cause false clicks (including that nasty number that I stated in my previous comment).
It’s probably only a matter of time before publishers start creating their own flash ads that play tricks like this to create their own increased click-throughs.
Hate to break the news, but viewers hat all ads that get in the way of the content trying to be accessed. Doesn’t matter whether it is a “floaty”, “curled page”, or a “drop down”. They are NEVER easy to close and we don’t like them. I would guess-timate that over 30% to 50% of the clicks on these “rich media” ads are mistakes.
I’m under the impression that Point Roll type of ads are not as targeted as Search Ads. Have any data on this?
Leave a Comment
Article Sponsor
More Features
-
Loading ...
Latest News
- Facebook to Serve Mobile Ads in Coming Weeks February 6th 2012 ADOTAS – According to a Financial Times report, Facebook will [...] more »
- Survey: 39 Percent of Mobile Users Responded to Super Bowl Ads Via Mobile February 6th 2012 ADOTAS - During the Super Bowl yesterday, mobile ad network [...] more »
- Sponsormob Leads the Way Into RTB for Mobile February 3rd 2012 ADOTAS – For more than half a decade, Berlin-based tech [...] more »
- Weird Study: Mobile Purchasing While in the Bathroom on the Rise February 3rd 2012 DM CONFIDENTIAL - According to 11mark, three-quarters of Americans with mobile [...] more »
- This Week’s New Hires February 3rd 2012 ADOTAS – Another week, another round of new gigs. Here [...] more »
- Two Surveys: What Are We Doing with Mobile Devices During the Super Bowl? February 2nd 2012 ADOTAS - With the Super Bowl fast approaching and the [...] more »
- Facebook Files for IPO, Seeks $5 Billion February 1st 2012 ADOTAS – Well, it finally happened: Facebook filed with the [...] more »
Features
- Reaching the Multi-Tasker in 2012 February 6th 2012
- Fuel Social Conversation with Web Content February 6th 2012
- Sponsormob Leads the Way Into RTB for Mobile February 3rd 2012
- Video: Social Media Monitoring Comes to “The Future of Engagement” February 3rd 2012
- Facebook’s Timeline: Meant for Brands All Along? February 3rd 2012
Spotlight
Sponsormob Leads the Way Into RTB for MobileADOTAS – For more than half a decade, Berlin-based tech firm Sponsormob has remained relevant in an industry characterized by [...] more...
Reader Favorites
Classifieds
- PS Technical Writer - SEO Data Analyst
- Interactive Project Manager
- Media Buyer
- PHP Software Engineer (Facebook Platform/Social AP
- SEO/Marketing Internship at Green Education Startu
Recent Comments
- The Difference Between Content Marketing and Custom Content | Using social media in content marketing | Scoop.it: [...] background-position: 50% 0px; background-color:#222222; background-repeat : no-repeat; }
- Ecommerce Industry Roundup – Week of 1/30/12 « Ecommerce x Acadaca: [...] Managing Your Privacy in a Public Digital World via Adotas - Believe it or not,
- Going Beyond Click-Throughs to Rope In Consumers: A White Paper Excerpt - ADOTAS | Conversion Rate Optimization (CRO) | Scoop.it: [...] background-position: 50% 0px; background-color:#222222; background-repeat : no-repeat; }
- Latest Weird News | Weird & Strange: [...] go to the bathroom without their mobile phone. Seventy-five percent of … Read more
